Harmonieharmony和声

Harmony results from simultaneous sounds. It creates the impression of polyphony and triggers, on the part of the listener, different sensations according to conscious or unconscious esthetic conceptions. These conventions are called harmonic rules. In the Western view, harmony is the most developed part of music theory. Harmony forms the vertical structure of a piece, whereas melody and rhythm form its horizontal structure. In music, harmony is realized through chords.

Metaphorically said,

melody is the body, and harmony is the clothes that change with fashion.1)

Character of Keys

In traditional music theory, the effect of sound sequences on the sensations (emotions) of the listeners have frequently been linked to the tonalities and harmonies use. However, as Johann Joachim Quantz already stated, these associations are not unavoidable:

There is no consensus concerning the effects of certain tonalities, be they major or minor. Our ancestors thought that each key had its proper character and proper expression of emotions. As the scales were not the same in their keys …; and as therefore almost every key had its own types of cadences, this opinion was fairly profound. In our days, however, where the scales of all big and small keys are similar, it is questionable if the properties of the keys are still like that. Some are still supporting the opinion of our ancestors; others however deny it und proclaim that each passion can be expressed in one key as well as in any other, if only the composer is able to do so. It is true, we have examples for this; there is proof that some have succeeded in very aptly expressing an emotion in a key that does not really seem to be most convenient for it. But who knows if the same piece, set in a different and more fitting key, was not even more efficient?2)

Accordingly, European musicians have arrived at conflicting and ambiguous judgments about different tonalities:

KeyMajorMinor
Cjoyful, martial, naughty, multipurpose, pure, noble, glorious, dullunclear, sad, angry, desperate, pathetic, wailing
C#/Dbcross-eyed, demonic, eccentric, sublimedesparate, nostalgic, tragic, malcontent
Dgrave, joyful, sharp, brilliant, triumphant, pretentious, fiery, briskserious, solemn, melancholic, gentle, grievous, dark
D#/Ebcruel, angry, loving, noble, solemn, glorious, manlydeterrent, scary, very sad, dire
Eloud, desparate, sad, harsh, fiery, brilliant, womanlysad, soft, weepy, feminine
Fdecent, angry, joyful, pleasant, modest, calmunclear, complaining, sad, melancholic
F#/Gbnoble, artificial, harsh, brilliantsorrowful, gloomy, melancholic, tragic, grumpy
Gsweet, soft, joyful, naive, gentle, quiet, graceful, pleasant, not sublimeserious, sad, melancholic, sullen, nostalgic
G#/Abblac, majestatic, heavenly, pious, noblelonging, sad, sublime
Ajoyful, humble, wailing, loving, aspiring, trusting, proud, deepsad, soft, complaining, pious, sleepy
Bblively, boastful, great, quiet, majestatic, noble, mellow, soft, light, dullunclear, terrible, sinister, sublime
Bdry, wailing, sublime, brilliant, brightlonely, sad, bizarre, sinister, soft, wild, brutal

In many cases, however, these ascriptions result from musical performance conventions rather than being innate musical temperaments:

For example, brass instruments are in a certain tuning: horns of old in F, trumpets in D … These instruments sound best in “their” keys. Anyone who wanted to compose festive music with timpani and trumpets, used to choose D major almost always, hence the reputation of this key to shine brilliantly. In some keys, the character attributed to them emancipated from its original instrument-practical reasoning: From the custom to let all the instruments play mourning music with dampers, the fame of E major arose to be a mourning sound; as trumpets played with dampers sound a note higher, they then stand in E instead of in D.3)

Theory of Musical Equilibration

Another approach is pursued by Daniela and Bernd Willimek's Theory of Musical Equilibration, which traces the effects of music to the “identifications of the listener with volitional processes”. The Willimeks define Equilibration as “identification with a will against change.”4) In major chords, the listener feels a certain tension, but agrees with it; however, he does not emotionally agree with minor chords. “The experience of listening to a minor chord corresponds to the information one receives when someone says I've had enough.”5) Through a self-constructed test on more than 2000 adolescent participants, Willimek and Willimek determined the effects of certain chords to be universal.

Emotional Effects of Harmonies according to Willimek/Willimek

Major tonic sober consent
Minor Tonic disagreement, grief (low), anger (loud)
Aeolian minor courage, adventure, suspense, danger, toughness
Dominant movement, aspiration, liberation
after minor tonic: acquisition of the minor character, standstill
Seventh chord resistance, protest, tearfulness, brakes, stepping
to minor tonic: takeover of the minor character, standstill
Intermediate dominant anticipation of the character of the expected new tonic; disappointment, pain, severe dismay
before major tonic: hope, departure to New
Subdominant in major
Sixte ajoutée in major: comfort, cosiness, faithfulness, warm-heartedness, warmth, togetherness, love, friendship
in minor: loneliness, separation, abandonment, lovesickness
Neapolitan sixth chord disappearance, death, abandonment, final pain, farewell forever
Decreased seventh chord Horror, despair, panic, horror, brooding sadness, melancholy
Excessive triad amazement, wonder, surprise, magic, transformation
Whole tone scale conditions in weightlessness, under water, in space, in dreams
Small sixth chord threat, danger, fear, feelings of anxiety

References


1) Kretzschmer: “Über deutsche Musik des Mittelalters.” In: Berliner allgemeine musikalische Zeitung 4 (1827), p. 139
2) Johann Joachim Quantz: Versuch einer Anweisung die Flöte traversiere zu spielen. Berlin 1752, pp. 138–139
3) Michael Gassmann: "Tonartencharakteristik: Welten zwischen C-Dur und h-Moll". In: FAZ, 27.9.2016
4) Willimek / Willimek 1997: 12
5) Willimek / Willimek 1997: 8